Intro – Amanda Luton (00:00:05):

It’s time for supply chain. Now broadcasting live from the supply chain capital of the country, Atlanta, Georgia, heard around the world. Supply chain now spotlights the best in all things. Supply chain, the people, the technologies, the best practices, and the critical issues of the day. And now here are your hosts.

Scott Luton (00:00:29):

All right. Good morning, Scott Luton here with you. Live on supply chain now along with my cohost and trusted business colleague, mr Greg white. Greg, good morning. Hey, how are you Scott? Doing fantastic. I’ll tell you, we’ve been on quite a roll. Uh, today’s live stream will continue that we’ve got an outstanding guest. You know, we’re continuing our collaboration, uh, on this show with, uh, Mike Griswold with gardener. Uh, you know, basically Greg, we’ve been sharing Mike’s, uh, insights and observations and experts around supply chain today and tomorrow. Right? Well, I keep telling people, Mike’s not only premier retail analyst in the industry, but he was a practitioner, so he knows of what he speaks and he speaks to a lot of people in the industry. So all the information he brings, this is fantastic. Yeah, agreed. Uh, so two quick notes before we bring Mike in.

Scott Luton (00:01:23):

Uh, first off, if you enjoy today’s live stream, be sure to check out our podcast wherever you get your podcasts from today. We published an episode earlier with vector global logistics part of art logistics with purpose series and we’ve featured a group called hungry Lauren knows with hungry. Fascinating story. Greg, I’m not sure if you’ve been able to check that out yet, but what a company on a mission to give forward. Yeah. W well, you know, we, our suite is across the courtyard from Hungary’s, so I’ve had the opportunity to talk with some of the folks there. What they’re doing is fantastic. First of all, it’s a great business concept, but what they’re doing in terms of philanthropy is, is great. Agreed. Agreed. Okay. And again, you can check our podcasts out wherever you get your podcasts from. Um, so real quick break out of out of the live streams and podcasts, you know, webinars mixed in. It’s been a busy time, but what’s one or two of your favorite moments here recently that really stands out? Well, you know, we had a great show with Sarah Barnes Humphrey yesterday with the super trends series. I think the uniqueness about that is Sarah’s perspective gives us an international perspective, right? She gets, um, and um, and she’s got a small tech company, so that’s fascinating as well. And, and also having a longer series like that where we get to talk about the different aspects of supply chain is great. Yeah. Um, you know, I think talking to all of these people live is to me is such a great opportunity for them to

Greg White (00:03:00):

share their knowledge with the audience globally. And I think it’s great. It’s been a bit of an awakening for me, probably for you too, Scott, that we need to think and speak globally even when even when we think and speak, I find myself sometimes too often thinking about or speaking about the United States solely and just on our continent, nor just on North America there, there’s Canada, Mexico as well. So we have to, we have to start to be more conscious of that. And I’m, you know, and I’m glad that we’ve been able to do that. And of course we’ve been able to bring so many people, the kids, the kids, the young professionals now from um, university of Georgia and the supply chain program there, um, DC, uh, who swag Lola and her husband Joseph, who’s going to join us on a later show, uh, that, that those insights from, you know, from people of all walks of life are what really energized me.

Scott Luton (00:04:05):

Agreed. Agreed. And we’re going to be doubling down our efforts to really represent all aspects of global supply chain. Right? Yeah. I’m scared to say in the end, after our conversation yesterday, right. Real quick. So hello to Kyle Reeves and, and John [inaudible] who are both tuned into us via LinkedIn live. You know, and John and Dusan is back with us. Do some weigh in, tell us on Facebook where you are tuned in from. I’d love to, we’d love to find that out. Okay. With no further ado, people aren’t here today to hear from me and you Greg there. He can’t be with my grids balls. So I to I want to welcome man. We want to welcome in Mike Rosewall, vice president analysts with Gartner, the world’s leading research and advisory firm who serves as a trusted advisor for over 15,000 enterprises and over a hundred countries. So welcome and Mike. Mike, good morning. How are you doing? Hey,

Mike Griswold (00:05:06):

I’m doing well. Thanks guys. Thanks for having me. And thanks for the kind words. Always good to spend time with you guys.

Greg White (00:05:11):

Yeah,

Scott Luton (00:05:12):

great to have you back with us. So, um, you know, my w we want to open up today’s segment on, you know, we can’t get enough good news in today’s challenging environment and you know, uh, a lot of folks are suffering economically or health wise or, or lots of other challenges out there. So in supply chain, we’ve, we’ve seen a variety of really uplifting stories that are good news. So, you know, Mike, what’s one of those stories has been on your radar here lately?

Mike Griswold (00:05:39):

Yeah, I think just maybe start with a general observation and then maybe a couple of specific examples. So I think in general has been fantastic to see how the supply chain, uh, in, in organizations has pivoted from what might’ve been their core focus area to other areas to help during the pandemic. So I live just outside of Boise, Idaho. We have a local winery as one example that went from producing um, wine and spirits to producing and using the alcohol to create gallons and gallons of sanitizer that they then distributed to our local hospital system. That’s one example. We have a couple of really small companies here in this state that make skis high, high end custom skis for people that ski of which I have not. One of them would, would probably recognize the name and what they’ve done because they deal really well with plastic, have converted and started to make face shields for first responders and healthcare providers. So to me, I think one of the big takeaways I have taken from this whole pandemic is how organizations have been able to recognize a core competency and then quickly pivot to deploy that core competency to help in areas around the pandemic, particularly in the areas of PPE, which I think we all now have had, you know, flattening the curve PPE, uh, are now in our vocabulary that three, four months ago we’re not in our vocabulary.

Greg White (00:07:17):

That’s right. Great point. Greg. New normal and unprecedented are reaching new Heights of usage in the English language. Exactly. That’s right. That’s right. Greg, what, what, what is stuck out from your, where you sit? Well, on the theme of pivots, I’m, you know, to be really specific, one of the things that we’re talking about now is the potential shortage of meat and other food supplies and what aren’t seeing is food service distributors. So food service distributors, they service schools and institutions and, and restaurants. And what I’ve seen them doing is opening their doors either for pickup or delivery to the public so that they can go and pick up goods that might otherwise get wasted or um, or not used in a timely fashion. So Buckhead meats is one example of that here in Atlanta, but there are companies all over the country that are doing this. And that’s going to be an important discussion as we talk about what’s going on in the future as we talk about what’s going on with some of the packing plants and things like that.

Mike Griswold (00:08:23):

Yeah, Greg, it’s interesting. I know, Scott, let me just maybe fast forward as briefly, I know we’re going to talk about the top 25 but one of the key trends that we’ve seen in these companies over the research that we did for the 2020 season is business model transformers and Greg, that’s a great example. And I was just on the phone before our call with one of the technology providers I work with in Europe who has a European food service type of operation who did the same thing. Well now they’re doing home delivery direct to the consumer. So this idea of the business model being transformed or at least slightly modified, definitely something we’ll talk a little bit later about in our top 25, but that’s a great example of that, Greg. Great. Yeah. Great.

Scott Luton (00:09:08):

Alright, well say hello to a couple of folks that are tuned in via the live stream from Patricia to Merck Ash to Jenny Froome who’s been on the show before, uh, from South Africa. Jenny board to our collaboration with you coming up soon and the great st pics organization, Tom Tom Valentine is on where there’s Tom, a big friend of the show. Love what Tom does. Uh, so just, that’s just a few of the folks that are tuned in. So good morning to everyone. Okay. Uh, want to share one of the good news store before we dive in. Um, earlier this week we talked about how Kroger has, has, has moved in to purchase 200,000 gallons of milk that was set to be destroyed. This milk was headed towards the, um, was made pre kind of preprint pandemic for food service and schools. All those are closed.

Scott Luton (00:09:56):

So they swooped in, bought the milk from the farmers and use their infrastructure to get it out to food banks across the country. That is an outstanding story. And of course, when you do something like that, you rely on global supply chains, rely on truck drivers. Right. So one last note here, we talked earlier this week about an organization up based in Oxford, Pennsylvania. Uh, run by CWA, mr CW Boyd who’s been in the trucking industry for 46 years. Unfortunately, as we all know, times are tough for the trucking industry right now. Um, and but despite that, despite, you know, their per per mile rates, uh, being cut as much as 70%, what we’ve heard about, he has Mr. Boyd has refused to cut the wages of his drivers. Uh, and that is an outstanding piece of good news and the industry needs more awareness. 311,000 for hire motor carriers in the U S about half of those according to, uh, the owner operator, independent drivers association, about half of those 311,000 are a single truck, you know, private carriers, you know, single drivers, small businesses, right.

Scott Luton (00:11:08):

And it’s a, it’s a tough time. So we’re trying to give that into that whole industry, which is a backbone of supply chain as much as visibility as we can. Alright, so moving right along, although I’d love to talk for a couple hours on some of the good news that we see. Um, you know, Mike, really the, the main, uh, Centerplate item here today is getting your latest observations around how COBIT 19 is impacting global supply chains. We’re all familiar with some of the, some of the OBS observations and, and, uh, the common, uh, uh, uh, observations we’ve seen across the industry. But what, what in particular here lately has gotten your attention? What, give us the up to date, Mike Griswold take on how COBIT 19 is impacting business.

Mike Griswold (00:11:51):

Yeah, I think when we, when we think about the impact, you know, I like to think about it and kind of three areas, demand, supply and capacity and certainly on the demand side, you know, I think we, we’ve certainly seen um, significant peaks and valleys. If we think about demand at a product level, product, location level. And I think one of the challenges that organizations have had is, is being able to quickly respond to those changes in demand. Some of that will will bleed into supply, which will ultimately bleed into capacity. But I think right now retailers are focused on inventory acquisition, meaning, you know, I think if we look at certain commodities, a forecast is relatively irrelevant because if no matter how much I get, I’m going to sell it all. So if I can get 2000 pieces, I’ll sell 2000 if I can get 3000 I will sell 3000 but we also have, I think a unique environment where we have, we have seen demand for other products that had a fairly normal, predictable movement completely shut down.

Mike Griswold (00:12:55):

So now I’ve got a bigger pool of product that has intermittent or even no demand. So managing that complexity I think becomes really important. And I think one of the things we’re starting to see, I’ve had a couple of conversations with a couple of technology providers. We’re actually starting to see retailers become more comfortable with this idea of accepting automated forecasts. Where, I mean Greg knows this from his previous experience, getting retailers to except a forecast or an order or a store order without touching it and helping. It was really hard. And I think Al, because people have so much other stuff to do, they’re being forced to let some of this autonomous forecasting start to happen. And what I’m hearing is some of those initial results are really good, right? Automatically managing the exceptions automatically creating some of these orders. And I think the last thing I want to touch on on the demand side is, you know, we need retailers and all businesses for that matter need a mechanism to flag this abnormal sales history.

Mike Griswold (00:14:04):

Treat it like an event. Because you know this sales pattern that we’ve seen, hopefully we don’t see it again. Right? We don’t have a flare up, we don’t have a research into this a year from now, whatever that situation may or may not happen. Our demand needs to be categorized today. The demand that we’ve seen for the last three months, these to be categorized as you know, unique so that our applications moving forward can handle it better. So those are some of the things I’ve seen in Scott and Greg on the demand side. Fantastic. Greg wants to get you to weigh in on what you heard there from my boy. We have talked a lot about this and that is, I mean Mike, Scott and I have done a few television or newspaper magazine

Greg White (00:14:52):

articles and they keep asking about this and particularly in grocery, one of the things that we say repeatedly is that part of the problem with managing demand is not the supply. It is how we manage demand. There is some person making a decision how much to buy and who wants to buy four pallets of toilet paper when they think the demand could stop at any time. Someone can point back to that person. But using technology enables you to one, solve the problem in the short term and to, as you said, noted as exceptional and, and exclude it from future forecast. And in truth, we’ve seen this, this technique work. This is a holdover in almost solely in the States by the way. We’ve seen the technique of automatic mated replenishment in grocery work in many countries around the world. Asia and Europe in particular already have automated systems. So we know it can work. It’s just resting that comfort of knowing my business more than any computer could out of somebody’s mind and trust, allowing them to, you know, to um, enable technology to help them solve this problem.

Mike Griswold (00:16:09):

Right point. And, you know, trust. We’ve heard that, uh, you know, we’ve made that observation before we trust has been woven into so many conversations, really the supply chain here lately and we’re going to continue to hear about that. Whether you’re trusting technology or your suppliers or your leadership. Right. Um, I want to get shot away in and, and, and Mike, I know we’ve got a lot more to tackle from some of your observations, but we’ve got an interesting comment here from Patricia and Patricia is, is following us on LinkedIn, but we can’t, we couldn’t show the LinkedIn comments. So we’re, we’re showing it via Facebook. Uh, she shares a quote in regards to PPE and other critical industries that are heavily dependent on imports. We should be rethinking the strategy and how to build a shorter and more reliable supply chain. Mike, I’d love for you to just get your quick take on that and Greg, you next.

Mike Griswold (00:16:58):

Yeah, I agree completely. We did a, we’ve got a future of supply chain, uh, study that we’ve, we’ve done here at gardener and we’re definitely seeing when folks, folks are asked around supplier risk and supplier, um, you know, how do we better mitigate that? We’re definitely seeing folks looking at, you know, India, Mexico, some of these other, I’ll call them less traditional, but they’re becoming more traditional markets. I also think, you know, I’ve read a number of um, positions around some of this PPE equipment that manufacturing continuing to be moved into let’s say North America, Greg, to kind of expand that definition, maybe not just the United States but North America so that we can shorten the supply chain. Well, one of the things that the pandemic has certainly is, has raised the general discussion of risk assessment and has accelerated organizations analysis of supplier risk and how, how, how well dispersed are we from a geographic perspective?

Mike Griswold (00:18:04):

I mean, again, to your earlier point, Greg, we saw some of this when you had um, you know, the, the tsunami and, and we’ve seen this through earthquakes in certain parts of the world that have made people at least stop and think about their supplier risk. This I think will be the final event that will finally push people to say, this needs to be a regular course of business. We have to regularly evaluate our supplier risk to understand, you know, how we will deal with situations like this. Uh, I think this will be the event that pushes people to do that much more prescriptively. Excellent. Well put, that’s typical Mike Griswold fashion. All right, Greg, you gotta follow up on that.

Greg White (00:18:50):

Look, the supply chain is simple. You build it, you sell it. Everything in between is a risk or a delay. Now, some of those risks and delays are worth it from an economic standpoint. But um, you know, to our commenters point, absolutely they can be simplified and we need to be, as Mike is talking about, we need to be more aware of those risks and what the potential cost of those risks are. Because mostly we have said, yeah, it’s a risk that we use China, but we haven’t, we haven’t quantified right potential of that risk. Now, one qualifying point I want to make here is that in the case of a tsunami or a hurricane or other natural disaster or even other pandemics or epidemics, we haven’t had the human intervention of ceasing commerce that we have. And it’s unlikely that we’ll ever do that again.

Greg White (00:19:44):

But we have to acknowledge and somehow try to determine what the impact would have been without this seismic societal disruption. Um, and also probably assess the risk that that could occur again. I mean if, if coven 19 does flare back up as we, you know, get back to work, then you know, it’s possible that we could intervene again. But, um, yes, the supply chain can be greatly simplified and um, you know, as some people have called it a China plus one strategy, I would argue China plus two or two plus China might be alternatives. There are all kinds of alternatives as well. Yep, yep.

Mike Griswold (00:20:28):

Yeah. Greg, you raised a great point. I mean, I think the other element to this you touched on which was the glow, the basically a global shutdown of commerce. I don’t know that, that this is not a value statement. I don’t know that that was in anyone’s playbook. It now has to be in everyone’s playbook, which is you might have of your estate pockets of your customers that will not have access to the traditional sales channel. That was never something we, we I considered or thought we needed to consider it. [inaudible] 19 and now in addition to the supplier risk, I think we also need to build it or a playbook, the commerce risk. And how would we get around that? Because we all saw, I think to varying degrees from the retail side, retailers ability to quickly turn on a ship to home capability to quickly ramp up a order online collect and store. I think that experience has vary greatly across different types of retailers based on how well prepared they were going into this.

Scott Luton (00:21:32):

Yeah, red point. Hey, uh, as John [inaudible] shared, uh, he, he agrees with you, Mike, how you kind of captured excellent idea to capture this time 2020 as a separate event though it is the new normal, it will not be the constant moving forward with respect to demand. So good stuff there from John B. All right. So we’re going to keep real quick before we keep driving with Mike and kind of dive into, uh, supply observations. I believe, uh, wanna give a quick shout out to Alex Muhammad Mohib, a professor from Wichita state university, the air capital of the world and Richard, tell which side this is on, man. Uh, Richard’s joined us, uh, via LinkedIn. Uh, Praveen has joined us, has got a question we’re going to try to get to here, uh, into the show a little bit. And Varun also, uh, joined us from, uh, only dent. Alright, so Mike, let’s keep, keep driving so much good stuff here. Let’s talk about some supply observations.

Mike Griswold (00:22:32):

Yeah, a couple. One. Um, one is we’ve seen, uh, across both the supplier side and the retailer side, significant range contraction, uh, which, you know, I, part of me says it’s unfortunate that it took an event like this for us to realize we’ve got too much stuff. Um, but there’s been a lot of range rationalization both on the supplier side and the retailer side. The question will be, you know, do retailers recognize now the overall assortment problem that many of them were faced with? And and do we stay with kind of this constricted highly customer centric range or do we or do we start to see kind of the proliferation back to where we were [inaudible] the other thing is, uh, I think a lot of retail organizations and their supply base have a pent up new item introduction surge coming at us. Wow. We have not had a lot of new item introduction for for all the right reasons.

Mike Griswold (00:23:33):

Uh, you know, if you think about retailers and their own stable of, of own brand products, right? That’s pent up demand. The re uh, the consumer products companies and others have their own pent up with new items. You know, how we manage that surge is going to be really important. And for me it will be fascinating to watch. And I think on the supply side what’s happening is I’m getting more and more interest in sales and operations execution. I’ve had, you know, five to seven different retailers tell me, Hey Mike, I guess what’s happened. We are cross-functionally collaborating to solve problems. I said, great, let’s build on that momentum and let’s start operationalizing and formalizing it into something that looks and feels like sales and operations execution. That’s going to be critical to understanding as States it businesses start to reopen. Being able to understand where my supply is. Do I need to move it? How do I move it? When do I move it? How do I put inventory in the right locations? That is all right around why we have SNOP. And I think people are already being forced to talk and collaborate together. You know, let’s build on that.

Greg White (00:24:45):

Hmm. Wow. Greg comments. Well, I mean I think that to me, the interesting thing there is what Mike said about, um, S and E, right? Uh, we’ve talked a lot about sales and operations planning, right? But what do you do as, as the great philosopher, Mike Tyson said, everyone has a plan until they get punched in the mouth. Right? I’ve heard that quote, uh, about 10 times a day, I think in recently. So how do you get what, you know, how do you respond? And one of the things we’ve talked a lot about here is response and SOE is about, is about recovery and response in the realities, right? It’s really sales and operation reality, uh, and execution against that. So, uh, I, I, um, it’s interesting to hear that coming and, and, um, you know, to see companies moving that direction. It also goes back to what we were talking about before is there’s so much, you know, this makes me think that there, there is so much in terms of demand that merchants can learn about range planning, meaning assortment planning, right?

Greg White (00:26:00):

How many skews of, of um, olive oil do you need? Um, there’s so much that can be learned from doing the things we were just talking about, Mike, in terms of, uh, demand forecasting and understanding demand in the store. And now there’s good reason to do that. Um, you know, there’s a possibility to fulfill those lower volume products in different ways, especially since so many people have become accustomed to buy online and curbside pickup of groceries. Right, right. So, particularly for grocery, I think that’s fantastic. I’m not sure we’ve seen the impact of Ray on ranch planning other industries of, of uh, fashion and apparel industries. All we know is that tops are selling it two to three times the rate of, of pants. We’re really looking forward to seeing as as Walmart announced last week a two hour delivery and how they’re going to be flexing their 5,400 stores. Um, you know, the months ahead. It’s gonna be really interesting time as always. It’s always interesting in supply chain e-commerce here lately. Um, before I kind of shift gears and, and, and recognize a few comments and questions that we’re getting in our stream, Mike, that you want to respond to. Anything that Greg just shared there?

Mike Griswold (00:27:18):

Yeah. I, I think the, the supply, I mean pick up Greg maybe a little bit on the fashion piece. I think the SNOP component for fashion becomes really important because I think, in fact, I’m working on a research note right now around the link between SNL E and how it helps you know, through a disruption, whether it’s coven 19 or whatever it might be. One of the use cases we’ve added is, is for fashion retailers to use SNOP to think about seasonal continuity, so on a state by state basis as States start to reopen fashion retailers have to ask themselves, I think the hard question, what season am I going to open with? Right? And for, for product that I already have in my sup, my internal supply chain, let’s say stuff that’s already here domestically, what am I going to do? Am I going to open the doors in a highly discounted environment?

Mike Griswold (00:28:09):

Meaning I’m marking down stuff and that’s the first experience the customers have. Am I going to skip a season and jump, let’s say right into fall. If in some States I’m not going to be business as usual until June or even July, so using SNOP to have that discussion around again, where’s my inventory, what’s my season look like? You know, what’s my markdown strategy going to be if I’m going to have one? All of those things I think are enabled much better through something like SNL, particularly for the fashion folks and I think that is the group that has been to me that industry is most at risk. The many of them were deemed not essential so they’re, they’ve been closed for a while. Some of their capabilities to do some of these online transactions have been limited. So that segment to me is going to be the one that I’m watching the most closely as States start to reopen to see how they’re going to open and how their, how their supply chains are going to respond.

Greg White (00:29:12):

Yeah. Interesting. Yeah, that’s a really good point. They have the greatest re, I mean they basically myths have exactly got to decide whether to shelve that. I mean companies like P V H I think is the parent company of Tommy Hill. You’re in a number of other brands. They’ve decided to shell their spring lines and bring them back I think next year or they had at one point. So there are lots of potential options there. Sorry Scott. Maybe

Mike Griswold (00:29:41):

one more real quick thing piggybacking on Greg. You know, if we think about the alternatives that fashion retailers had in terms of the discount channel, you know, the Burlington coat factory is the TJX is of the world as a, as an offer, as a release valve for excess inventory. You know, for what I’m hearing and what our research is showing is that valve is gone, those outlets are full. Those outlets now have the pick of the litter in terms of excess inventory they want to take. So that, uh, that lever or that mechanism, that fashion retailers may have had in the past to, to let off some of this inventory steam, if you will. That’s fine. So that page, that page and the playbook is ripped out, they now need a different way to think about that.

Scott Luton (00:30:24):

Well, you know, uh, that’s right. Not taking anything away from the food industry, which has its own set of challenges. But yeah, gosh, leading and managing half fashion global supply chains has gotta be a little more complex and cans of green beans. Right? Cause there’s no shirt, no shelf stability there. All right. So changing gears for a second here. I want to recognize a couple of comments and questions from the streams here. Uh, first up, uh, Thiebaud on LinkedIn, he says, uh, supplier risk management has now been shown as an absolute critical day to day function from raw materials value adding manufacturers and distributors. Right up to LSP, uh, good stuff there. And then, uh, Veron has got an interesting comment and then a question that we’re going to pose to you. Each of you, uh, hello, all cash is King at these times. Customers are not paying as, they don’t as, they can’t sell cars in turn, manufacturers don’t have cash to pay their suppliers. How does one manage supplier relations at the present time without jeopardizing future partnerships? That deserves a, probably a fuller conversation, but any quick observations there, uh, from, from both of y’all and Mike, we’ll start with you.

Mike Griswold (00:31:36):

Yeah, I think it’s a great question and it certainly is part of the new reality, right? In terms of, of managing the funds you have coming in. How do you disperse them, not only to your associate base, but to your supplier base? Are they, one of the things that we’ve talked about a lot here at Gardner and written research on is supplier segmentation. I think one of the things that now needs to be added into the way in which we, we segment our suppliers is, you know, not so much financial stability, but how about financial reliability? How reliable am I to that supplier’s longterm longevity. And what I’ve seen some retailers start to do is kind of turn that pyramid upside down and say, Hey look, I might have a, a tier two or tier three supplier in terms of how I segment them, but I’m a big chunk of their business there.

Mike Griswold (00:32:32):

While it might be limited, the skews they provide me are highly differentiating. I need to pay them first. Where where someone say a larger consumer products company that I know has a little bit deeper pockets, maybe I pay them a little bit late or maybe I set up a deferred payment plan with them. Um, but I really have to focus on these smaller suppliers that I’m a big chunk of their business because if they go under, uh, because I don’t pay them that there’s a portfolio product that I now can’t deliver to my consumer. So I think that the way that we traditionally have segmented suppliers I think is also now going to evolve with this new financial lens applied to it.

Scott Luton (00:33:18):

Hmm. Greg? Supplier relationships.

Greg White (00:33:21):

Yeah. I think one of the things that you’ve got to think about is who do you already have a good relationship with, right? And who do you have a good open dialogue with and go to those people among the first, and I agree, you’ve got to assess the relative importance of a vendor. And that doesn’t just mean volume, as Mike said. That could be because of the uniqueness of their product. And very often the vendors that you’re going to have the tightest relationship with are going to be your largest vendors. I mean, speaking as a retailer, it sounds like they both might be in the automotive industry. Uh, OEM, automotive, like, uh, industry. Um, so you know, you know who your top vendors are and work with them. Um, you know, and I, I I think look, the best negotiating methodology is complete transparency. Um, often nobody can make you do anything in a negotiation, even if they know why you’re doing it. It’s still up to you to take a win-win or no deal situation. So, um, I think you’ve gotta be really open with your suppliers and you’ve gotta be, um, you’ve got to identify who you can work with and identify who you can. As Mike said, you can either create a plan with or drag a little bit and get, you know, and you might have to play on a little bit of relationship capital there for sure.

Scott Luton (00:34:49):

Or be dragged one of my, one of my favorite phrases there. All right, so real quick, I’m going to read off two or three comments from the audience and then we’re going to dive back into capacity with Mike Griswold. Uh, alright, so our friend Claudia, who’s going to be on the show here, I think next week, new business models can help solve the inventory glut. Good stuff. There, uh, from our friend Tom Valentine, he shares covert 19 has made the demand for true real time visibility to your supply chain, both upstream and downstream. Critical. It drives SNOP and S snowy. Good stuff. Tom Valentine. Great to have you here. And then one more, which is going to lead us right into this next segment is from a professor Mohib, uh, from Wichita state university goes shocks quote, it is a great opportunity for us to update our current demand supply capacity, AI models to be more adaptive. I think we are learning a lot now that we can be more predictive or even prescriptive during panic attacks. Good stuff there. Yeah, that’s actually a really good point. Um, cause what Mike and I were talking about about identifying it as an as exceptional, it’s never forgotten by an AI model, right? Artificial intelligence is just actual intelligence that never fails. Essentially. You never fail to remember it. You never fail to apply it. You always apply it equally. Um, so that, that’s actually a really, really good point. Yep.

Mike Griswold (00:36:18):

Uh, it, it is and, and I, and I think the, the, the AI piece of that’s really important because that will start to automate and capture some of these insights so that when we have, you know, I think, I think there’s a general school of thought that is that this, well we hopefully don’t say anything like COBIT 19 again, we will see disruptions that look and feel like this and being able to use AI and machine learning to better predict how to respond to that from a demand perspective I think becomes critical. The other thing, Scott, I want to comment real quick on Tom’s comment. When we look at some of the research again, I’ll maybe sneak a little plug for the top 25. When we look at our top 25 research, one of the things those companies have invested in over the years is visibility and visibility platforms and visibility capabilities compared to, um, companies that aren’t necessarily in the top 25. That has not been a priority for them. So that was a great call out on Tom’s part because visibility is huge and will continue to be huge as we deal with different types of disruptions.

Scott Luton (00:37:22):

Absolutely. I wish I was in the visibility business. It is going to be more and more if we thought we’ve heard about visibility and the demands for it in recent years. Just wait for the months ahead. Hey, you know, I’m going to call a quick audible and rip a page out of our playbook here because surely one of the things that got you to pivot and that’s right. One of the things that you, uh, Mike and Greg both got passionate about was that the fashion industry and the retail industry. We’ve got a great comment and question here from Patricia, who’s, who’s with us on LinkedIn. I want to share this with you and get your take and then we’ll, we’ll get to the capacity of the moment, the fashion. So Patricia says here, Patricia V on LinkedIn says the fashion outlets are still closed, including online. What should they do if someone returns something, if they try an item at the store, why have they struggled to keep their online site online site open and shipping out a comment? Sarah, I’ll start with you, Mike.

Mike Griswold (00:38:19):

Yeah, I think you know that when I look at the fashion industry in general, you know, there, and again, I don’t want to necessarily paint with a broad brush, but their adoption of technology, um, particularly science-based technology has been slower than, than other areas, other segments or retail. So things like keeping up with distributed order management, keeping up with, you know, the uh, demand sensing, demand creation tool, um, inventory visibility, right? Some of those, those basic blocking and tackling capabilities, um, have not necessarily been as high a priority for some of those fashion retailers. And therefore they are, they have not been necessarily as equipped to respond as quickly to the surgeon demand. You know, just because people could go to a store, it doesn’t mean they still don’t want to buy clothes. Right? So the ability to service that customer, I think in the volume that we’ve seen to the, to, to the, to Greg’s earlier comment about commerce shutting down or at least physical commerce shutting down, I think they, many of them were not equipped for that search.

Mike Griswold (00:39:26):

I think the other thing that, this is not a fashion unique problem. You know, colleague of mine, Tom Ben Wright, has been talking for years around returns. Uh, and the ability to handle returns has been one of, if not the single biggest problem we’ve had any commerce, uh, on the retail side. And we’ve seen anywhere from a 15 to 25% increase in returns on top of, you know, fashion, which was already at 30% returns because people are saying, Hey, I can’t get to a store, you know, I’m going to buy three of these in three different colors and three different sizes. And, you know, that volume we, we were not an and are not prepared to deal with. So, you know, I, I think, you know, it’s been a scaling problem. I would say, to answer the question specifically, it’s been a scaling problem. Uh, and I think we’re still dealing with a scaling problem, particularly the fashion side. Yep. Hey, real quick, Greg, before you weigh in. Uh, when Mike mentioned that just because folks aren’t in stores doesn’t mean they don’t want to purchase clothes. Our chief marketing officer over here had a big, she was nodding her head, so you got a thumbs up on that point, Mike. All right, Greg,

Greg White (00:40:35):

let’s, let’s talk, uh, talk to Patricia’s questions there. Yeah. Well, I think it’s important to distinguish between fashion and maybe fashion basics or other apparel. Retail for instance, Kohl’s was very equipped, right. Um, to both to both do outbound and reverse commerce in, in this environment. But companies like LVMH who may be selling their goods directly, not so much, and those high fashion brands and high fashion retailers, um, fall into the category, more of them fall into the category, Mike, that you were talking about. Uh, and I, I think it’s important for us to distinguish between the clothes that most of us buy a great right and the clothes that the Kardashians buy. And there are different, you know, marketplaces and different levels of technology though the, the opportunity exists at every level of, of soft goods retail. I would argue too as, as Claudia was talking about earlier, to revisit business models where a certain portion of the goods are wasted by, by part of the, of the model, right?

Greg White (00:41:46):

Where they are meant to go to TJ max or um, Mark down to some extent and then sold off. So if we embrace the technology that Mike’s talking about, then we can be a bit more precise in identifying how many of which products go into what store, in what colors so that we don’t have these massive over, uh, over capacity of product versus what we know demand is going to be. Right. Um, and a lot of that is driven by how merchants I, being a former merchant myself, a lot of that is driven by how merchants are motivated. You’re motivated, right on GMR ROI and, and you do that by putting a lot of product out there and assuming that a bunch of it is going to get marked down. So we need to evaluate, um, some internal processes as well in order to change some of these things.

Scott Luton (00:42:39):

Yeah. And speaking of evolving business models, uh, Claudia had mentioned that today Alibaba announced online luxury outlets to attract millennials. So lots and lots of pivots, uh, ahead, uh, professor Mohib, Greg, going back to your comment earlier, he likes it. China plus one or two or two plus China. He gives that two thumbs up for that later. New ladder, new model, lots of wins. I’ll state love happening. Hey Mike, we’re going to dive into capacity. This will be our most succinct one before we talk about the top 25, but where are you going to comment on what Greg just shared?

Mike Griswold (00:43:17):

Yeah, I think I agree with Greg completely, right? We don’t want to paint all fashion apparel retailers with the same brush. There certainly are some distinctions and I agree completely with the observation on goals. I think the other thing that people, and maybe it does segue as Scott into the capacity piece, I think one of the things, apparel, let’s call them apparel retailers in general and other segments of retail are going to have to consider is the markdown piece, right? We have some, let’s call them maybe higher end apparel folks where you know, markdown is a four letter word, right? They’re going to need to get over that. Uh, or I mean, to me it’s better to get 20% of something than that a hundred percent zero. So I think that’s one, one approach. And the second thing is store to store transfers. Uh, I think there are some segments of retail, some retailers in particular that kind of thumb their nose at sorta store transfers.

Mike Griswold (00:44:06):

Uh, again, I think in the environment, going back to Tom’s earlier comment around visibility, you know, I think having visibility and being ready to pre-position product particularly, I think it becomes, if we think about the capacity element of this, you know, the country is not going to open at the same rate. So large us North American retailers are going to have to take a look at where is this capacity going to open up and do I have inventory there? And if I have inventory in places that aren’t going to open up, I’m going to have to seriously consider how do I get it to places that are going to open up. So that transfer piece I think is going to have to be a viable option for folks.

Greg White (00:44:49):

Good point. No, I think that’s an excellent point. And to put the goods in the right store to begin with. I mean, you know, ages ago we talked about micro merchandising, right, where you don’t stuff a bunch of sweaters into the stores in South Florida, right? I mean some of that, not to that extent, but some of that still does happen. Um, and it’s, you know, it’s another part of the puzzle we need to address.

Scott Luton (00:45:14):

Yup. All right, so I’ve got two other questions, but I’m hoping we can answer these enlightening round style. They’re, they’re not lightening round questions, but let’s see if we can answer them very briefly. And then we’re going to talk about the supply chain top 25, which is always compelling content that comes up each year. So first question, and we’ll pose this to Mike first. This comes from it’s Valentine’s day on LinkedIn. This is Joseph Valentine along with Tom that they’re keeping the conversation going. Yeah, there we go. Do you think contactless returns will become a more prevalent option in the fashion space? I might start with you.

Mike Griswold (00:45:49):

Yeah, I agree. It’s a great question. Yes. Short answer, yes. I think that’s going to happen. I think the other thing that has happened, Greg talked a little bit about curbside pickup. I think retailers that have offered that are going to have to find a way to continue to offer that. Uh, I think we’re going to see a split between the traditional buy online pickup in store transaction where someone’s going to get out of their vehicle and actually navigate a store to a buy online, um, curbside pickup. Um, so people are gonna have to figure out, you know, how to carry that service forward because I think there are segments of retailer’s customer base that have actually liked that transaction, have gotten a great experience. You know, I bought golf balls from Dick’s that way. So my question now is I have a golf ball. I like, do I need to go into Dick’s to get the golf ball or can I do curbside pickup and have someone come out and drop, uh, you know, a box of balls in my car. So in addition to that return question, which was a good one from Joseph, I think this curbside pickup is another, um, transaction that people were going to have to figure out how to keep going.

Scott Luton (00:46:58):

Yep. Greg,

Greg White (00:47:00):

I think that’s an excellent point. And you know, the thing I would point out is that Mike probably buys fewer golf balls than other golfers above average call for buy. They don’t play him for money. Good point. Of course things are going to change how we both buy product and I think we’re really good on that side of the equation. Um, though we are still learning things amazingly just curbside pickup but also, um, you know, in the returns process as well return sensitive. And I can see, you know, we talk with Tony Sharada and his group at the reverse logistics association and we talk a lot about circular economy. I can see companies starting to get aggressive. Mike, I think Tom will be happy to hear this come in. Right? I see companies starting to get aggressive on how to prevent returns rather than facilitate them in a less costly fashion. Good point there.

Scott Luton (00:47:59):

And uh, the RLA, the reverse logistics association is a great resource to for best practices. You can go to [inaudible] dot org for more information there. Okay. You know, the really neat thing is, uh, I love when folks in the stream as questions come in, they start answering the questions and other and that dialogue. That’s right. So that’s great. Um, the second lightning round question comes from Tom Valentine and Thiebaud in the LinkedIn stream was, was answering Tom’s questions. So he says, Kobe has opened our eyes to looking at technology to provide true real time visibility to their supply chain. Spreadsheets are static, not dynamic. The supply chain is dynamic. What cost effective tools do you see midsize and small companies doing to address this issue? So a lightning round, Mike, what you think? Yeah,

Mike Griswold (00:48:49):

no, I think that that’s an area that I, I mean I’ll be transparent. I don’t cover that area so I don’t have thoughts on, on the technology space. I know there is one, I know what’s emerging. We have some visibility, lots of visibility research. I guess if anyone is looking for more insights on that just to have them, you can guys can just ping me Mike dot [email protected] and I can, I can forward some stuff to you. Um, but it’s just not an area that I spend time in.

Scott Luton (00:49:16):

Yep. Fair enough. Greg,

Greg White (00:49:18):

I think a lot of companies are compiling their own using business intelligence or whatever the heck we’re calling it these days. Types of tools and, and real time integrating into their systems, but also integrating into, um, red, uh, generally available information on the internet as well. Uh, and there are innumerable solutions in that regard.

Scott Luton (00:49:42):

Yeah, great point. Hey, and just a couple of tools that we’ve leveraged currently or for our previously that had been really effective. Slack of course is getting a lot of air cover right now as much as zoom, zoom and Slack. I’ll tell you it’s been a, uh, facing frenzy and then Trello is a really, it doesn’t quite get as much visibility, but Trello is a really interesting tool. We’ve seen a good successful collaboration take place on. Alright, so we’re going to move right along as much as I’d love to keep up the Q and a is my favorite part of these live streams and our webinars. But, uh, Mike, let’s talk about the Gartner supply chain. Um, top 25 for 2020. And for the sake of time, we’re going to move past the background. We’ll have to share some of that next time. Sure. Let’s talk about the criteria, uh, that you,

Mike Griswold (00:50:28):

you bake into the 2020 rankings and any, any, um, new updates on that over 2019. Yeah, sure. So, um, we’ve been doing this for this, this will be year 16. You know, the list starts with, um, fortune and Forbes, uh, company lists need to be publicly traded, 12 billion in revenue. Uh, need to have a supply chain, need to have 50% of your revenue coming from physical products, so that, that gets us to a list of around 300 companies globally. So that’s around the world. Um, different industries, different segments. So it gives us a pretty good population to start with. You know, with the, the criteria itself is 50%, um, financial measures. So the publicly traded companies, we gather all their financials. Uh, we look at, um, return on physical assets, which is new this year. I’ll talk about that briefly. Revenue, uh, and inventory turns.

Mike Griswold (00:51:23):

We, we’ve enhanced, uh, what we used to call CSR, corporate social responsibility. We’ve now enhanced that to what we call ESG, environmental society governance. Um, because we’ve added a couple of new measures to that. So, uh, and then the other 50% is a 25% pure vote. So supply chain professionals, like I’m sure many of the people on this event right now, um, cast votes, we had a 150 ish this year. Um, and then we have an analyst component, right? All of that goes into the hopper, uh, and out spits, you know, an index composite score for each of those measures. Uh, and then that’s how we, we ha we create the ranking. We have, um, five companies that are masters. Uh, those companies have had a top five composite score, seven in the last 10 years. And then we, and then we ranked the other, um, companies in that pool of 300, um, to get our list of, of 25.

Mike Griswold (00:52:19):

So at a very high lightening round, you know, that’s how the methodology works. Uh, in terms of 2020, though, we made some what I feel are pretty significant changes. So, uh, we moved from return on assets, uh, to a return on physical assets, which means we’ve tightened the calculation to really be the assets, the supply chain controls, property, plant equipment and inventory. Uh, and then we took out of the numerator, um, the other, so if you think about the, the calculation, you know, total assets on the top, which would include things that happen from acquisitions that the supply chain doesn’t control. So we stripped all of that out. Uh, and it had probably the biggest impact on shaping the list is that change to return on physical assets. The other thing that we did that I think had a pretty substantial change is we increased the weighting on the ESG component.

Mike Griswold (00:53:18):

It was 10% of the waiting. Now it’s 15% of the weighting because we added two new measures. So we had already done a lot around the environment. So working with a UN global compact, um, GRI, CDP. So folks that deal in the CSR environment will recognize those names. Um, but now we’ve added Ethisphere and Bloomberg, um, to provide us an ethical company list and a gender equality index. So we’ve now added that into the mix in terms of how we evaluate the supply chains. Um, and then we lowered the waiting on inventory. Uh, I won’t go into all the gory details around that. We just lowered that. So the five inventory was 10, it’s now five. We took the five and gave it to ESG. The last thing that I want to call out, uh, and I’ve, I’m doing my best to over communicate this is, you know, the, the, we, we added CSR in 2016 based on feedback from the community and a recognition that the supply chain was being instrumental in driving sustainability for organizations.

Mike Griswold (00:54:24):

We also recognized in 2020 that there’s also work that the organizations are doing around their workforce, which is why we wanted the ethical company representation and we wanted the gender equality in general. We recognize the huge contributions that supply chains make in driving a better planet and driving sustainability. So in that regard, beginning in 2021, if an organization has zero for an ESG score, they will not be ranked. What does that mean? I can tell you right now, there are two companies in that list of 30 that have zero for ESG and in 2022 companies will need a minimum score of three. So it is hugely important to us. Um, it’s, it’s hard for me to say you are one of the 30 best supply chains in the world. If you have an ESG score. Zero. What I, what I’m not saying is that those companies don’t care about the planet. What I am saying is the work that they’re doing is not recognized by our methodology and that’s important to us.

Scott Luton (00:55:34):

Excellent. There’s so much to tackle real quick though for the second time. Yeah. Mike, we’ve got a question from a Varun ask about, is the top 25 available as a download, where, what’s the best Avenue for folks to check that out?

Mike Griswold (00:55:47):

Yeah. So, um, with all of the disruption, you know, we, we typically reveal this at our biggest supply chain events. Um, those have all been postponed. Um, so we’re doing a, uh, a live webinar on May 19th, where we will do the reveal of the companies. We’ll also talk about, I alluded to briefly, you know, one of the key trends, the business model transformers. We’ve, we’ve got three trends. Um, so that webinar on the 19th is 10:00 AM Eastern time, uh, open to anyone and everyone that’s interested in learning more about the top 25. Um, and then I’ll be doing a replay of, um, at 8:00 PM that by the night of the 19th for folks in Asia Pacific. So the 19th is when we will reveal that in the webinar. And then the published note should be available at noon-ish, uh, right after the webinar. Yep. Outstanding. All right, so Greg, coming back to you. So, um, quick follow up on what Mike shared prior to that webinar and then we’re fortunate to have Mike come back after the big reveal the week after and take a deeper dive. Right, right. So, so speak first to a lot of what Mike shared around the rankings.

Greg White (00:56:59):

Well, I mean, first of all, I think that one of the most important things is the increased value of ESG there. Um, and, um, you know, because that goes to a lot of the things that are becoming prominent in supply chains. What we’ve seen is that, and Mike, it seems like it wasn’t so long ago that we were saying supply chain is not, is no longer a necessary evil. It’s a co it’s a competitive differentiator. And now I think it’s even more than that. It is a big portion of your brand identity. Because if you, if, because people can easily find out some of the ESG components of your supply chain, they can find out if your supply chain is efficient and cost effective. And if you have, you know, if you have forced labor or you know, any quality or any or unsustainable practice in your supply chain, then that is reflecting on your entire brand. I mean, entire brands are being implicated. Um, and, and, um, the consumer, as the consumer has become more empowered, that’s a more valuable component of, of the evaluation of supply chain. So to me, the big, the big thing there is that the Gartner and Mike in particular have taken the time and the effort to make sure that we’re promoting ethical fair business practice as well as efficient and cost effective practice.

Mike Griswold (00:58:29):

Outstanding. Hey, real quick, before we talk about the other webinars or follow up on that commentary, I want to point out to our audience that, especially those on LinkedIn, Amanda has posted the link to the Gardner revealed the registration link so you can go straight there. Oh, thank you. You bet. And then of course we’re, uh, we’ve got our followup event or uh, May 27th and you can find that there at [inaudible] dot com. Mike, I think you were going to follow up on what Greg just shared. Yeah, just real quick, you know, just a, um, a kind of a quick decomposition of what we look at. Just as one example to Greg, what you were speaking about when we, we get, um, you know, we partnered with CDP as I mentioned. Um, you know, folks submit their, their sustainability efforts to CDP and they get graded.

Mike Griswold (00:59:15):

Ella just as one small component CDP grades on carbon water and forests. So it’s, it is a very encompassing approach to how we’re treating the planet. Um, and, and again, great to your point, I think it just reemphasizes you know, well, I started at AMR, it feels like a long time ago we wrote a book called supply chain saves the world. It was probably well ahead of its time, but I think, you know, it’s probably not hyperbole to say that the supply chains of today are in fact maybe not saving the world, but they’re definitely helping the world get through this pandemic. And I’ve never seen, other than we may have joked about this last time, other than, you know, Jack Ryan on the Amazon series as a supply chain analyst that that made supply chain cool. I think we’ve never had as much exposure, you know, good and bad, uh, around the supply chain and what it does for, for the world. Um, you know, throughout this, uh, this pandemic. Yeah. Excellent. Agree.

Scott Luton (01:00:18):

All right, we’ve got to wind the conversation down. We’ve got a little, a little bit of feedback from John B on LinkedIn. I really enjoyed the session. Thanks for continue to bring value, Scott, Greg and Mike, so really appreciate that. Appreciate everybody that tuned in. We’re going to go over just a minute or two here, but we want to make sure folks know where to go to get more information. We have put the Gardner direct link out, I think across all, all five of our social feeds. Uh, the webinar, the followup webinar with Mike Griswold. We’re going to dive deeper, uh, is May 27th. You can find that on our site and bring your folks, everyone tuned in. The thing is, as much as Greg and I both enjoy Mike Griswold’s insights and perspective, you know, get all the comments and the questions from the audience.

Scott Luton (01:01:00):

That makes it even better hopefully for everyone. So bring that with you. Whether you go to the or webinar, you come to ours, bring your, you know, your voice with you. We want to dive into that and pose your questions and comments to Mike. All right. Beyond the Gartner webinar, we want to offer one other great resource to folks. Of course, unfortunate hurricane seasons right around the corner. That will certainly make things even more challenging for many global supply chains. There’s a free webinar with the folks over at resilience three 60 coming up on May 14th and you can get a lot of their insights on how to mitigate and manage the risk associated with the upcoming hurricane season. And then finally, two quick points. And Mike, thanks for being a great sport here. Um, Greg, we’ve got supply chain trivia coming up. Uh, May 13th a little departure from most of our content, right? Yeah, yeah. Well, I mean, will mr inventory Demetrios coolest? Will he defend his title belt? It was a very close race between he and several other experts. Mike, if you have the time, I’d love to see. Okay. But I’m going to say, you know, depending on your level of, of comfort, you may want to use an alias because I’m not as confident that he could win as, as, as a he, he wanted to be

Greg White (01:02:20):

and he didn’t reveal himself personally until right at the end. So, um, that was a what a great fun event. Right? But it is, and we’re using a new platform. We had a few glitches last time, but, um, we’re using a new platform and we’re going to make sure that everyone gets to participate. We had Nickeel in India two 40 and two 30 in the morning. It’s time actually competing and competing strongly until finally internet slowdowns. Um, just kind of disabled them. But, um, but anyway, we hope we’ve solved a big, big portion of that this time around. Always continuous improvement. We all, you know, it’s a journey. Never with the finish line. Hey, uh, Jenny Froome who’s doing some big things with say pics in South Africa for, for supply chain, uh, she chimes in with, it’s true that dark clouds have several linings. Absolutely.

Greg White (01:03:12):

Jenny, we appreciate that. Hope you and your family are doing well. Uh, one last thing. Uh, we are leading a breakout session on the future of supply chain at, uh, the vet Lana third quarter to three summit. It’s gonna be May 14th, Kay KPMG is hosting that, but come check that out. We’ve got Terriel Hanlin with gray orange. We have Kathy Maura Robertson with legit logistics TNI, uh, trends and insights all, but you’re both sitting on that panel, Greg, that’s going to shape up to be an outstanding event, right? Yeah, I think it will, that’ll be interesting, the juxtaposition of supply chain and veteran careers, right? That’s right. Uh, you can learn more at [inaudible] dot com for any of that. Hey, if you, if you can’t find one of the things we’ve mentioned today, whether it’s a gardener resource or one other things, shoot us a note to Amanda at [inaudible] dot com and we’ll serve as a resource for you. Hey, Mike, uh, fi if you could give us one final challenge or key observation that folks really need to take from this conversation and let’s make sure folks know how to reach out to you. Yeah.

Mike Griswold (01:04:17):

So Mike Roswell, Mike died [email protected]. I think the thing that I’ve observed is that no one, uh, no one, no one organization gets through this alone. It’s about the ecosystem of partners that you’ve created to Greg’s earlier point around suppliers. And the question around suppliers, um, everyone needs to, to be comfortable reaching out across their ecosystem, you know, to get through this because no one will get through this in isolation.

Greg White (01:04:45):

Yeah. Outstanding. Uh, and, and folks, even though Mike and the list is a top 25 list is focused on these large global companies, I promise you that whether you’re a small business leader, mid sized business, you’re going to have some great key takeaways that that will improve your organization. Right? Greg? No doubt. Yeah. I mean there, there’s some, there things that any size entity can learn from what the best in the industry are doing. And as Mike said, they’re sort of limited to assessing public companies because so much of the data that

Scott Luton (01:05:18):

they want is available. Um, and, but that doesn’t mean that there’s not a lot that companies of any size can apply here. Yep. Abs well said. Both of you gentlemen. Hey, it’s been a pleasure. Thanks so much Mike, for your time once again this month. Greg, the same for you. I love these conversations. I love the interaction with the audience. Uh, I’ve learned, I’ve got about eight pages of notes, Mike, so thanks so much. Uh, one of the things, Mike Griswold, vice-president analysts with Gartner for joining us here today, along with Greg white, my cohost and trusted business advisor, uh, to our audience. Thanks so much for bringing it today. We look forward to our next live stream with you. And with all that said, have a great week. Stay safe, everybody brighter, brighter days. Certainly lie ahead and we’ll see you next time here at supply chain now. Thanks. Thanks everyone.